Imagine finding yourself in a bewildering situation where the HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) mistakenly believes you are someone else. This has become my reality, and it’s having a significant financial impact—about £450 each month.
Last November, HMRC erroneously linked a stranger's employment records to my national insurance (NI) number. This means I can see details about their job, including when they started, their payroll number, and their salary.
Due to this mix-up, HMRC is taxing me as if I hold two jobs and earn double what I actually do. On top of that, they’ve added a tax adjustment based on the assumption that I owe them for taxes not paid last year. This has created a significant strain on my finances, costing me approximately £450 every month due to inflated tax and NI contributions.
In an effort to resolve this, I spent a frustrating 90 minutes waiting to speak with an advisor, only to find out that they hadn’t yet addressed the issue. It feels like I'm caught in a bureaucratic nightmare.
This story resonates with another individual who faced a shocking situation when HMRC mistakenly declared her deceased after confusing her NI number with that of a deceased stranger. The most alarming part of these blunders isn’t just the errors themselves but the casual disregard that seems to follow them.
In my case, HMRC explained that during a tax code review that coincided with a job change I made last year, their system mistakenly matched my employment information with that of another woman who shares some personal details with me. Fortunately, our NI numbers remained distinct, allowing for a resolution.
They have since sorted out the confusion and plan to refund the excess tax I’ve overpaid, which will appear in my next payslip. Additionally, they are offering a compensation of £75. I was curious if this incident, especially since I could view the other woman's employment details, constituted a data breach requiring notification to the Information Commissioner’s Office. HMRC responded by stating that this was not necessary because no sensitive information like her name, address, or date of birth had been disclosed.
We always welcome letters, though we cannot respond to each one individually. If you’d like to share your thoughts or similar experiences, please email us at consumer.champions@theguardian.com or send your letters to Consumer Champions, Money, The Guardian, 90 York Way, London N1 9GU. Don’t forget to include a daytime contact number. Note that all submissions and publications are subject to our terms and conditions.
